Dangerous Nostalgia: Poll Reveals Americans’ Risky Obsession with the Past - Boomer insight

Andy Peters

Dangerous Nostalgia: Poll Reveals Americans’ Risky Obsession with the Past

We all feel nostalgia now and again, but a recent poll revealed that most Americans think things were better 50 years ago. The poll also shows that people’s political preferences influence their sense of nostalgia, as more Republicans feel nostalgic than Democrats. It seems that everyone’s a little homesick in the past, but why? Let’s find out.

The Research

Editorial credit: Andrey_Popov / Shutterstock.

The Pew Research Center surveyed Americans in April 2023 and found that 58% believe that life was far better 50 years ago. For Republicans, this figure jumps to 72%. Of course, people have always felt nostalgic, but this figure suggests that people really aren’t happy with how America is at the moment.

Thinking About the Future

Editorial credit: Hyejin Kang / Shutterstock.

The study also looked at people’s views of the future, specifically how they think America will be in 2050. 68% of people said they thought the US economy would be weaker, and 71% believed the US would be less important in the world. 77% believe the country will be more politically divided, and 81% think the wealth gap will grow even further.

Differences in Race

Editorial credit: TippaPatt / Shutterstock.

Naturally, the study did show that people’s race may also affect how they feel about the future. Compared to other races, white Americans were more likely to believe that America’s economy would struggle in the future. Even so, most participants (80%) agreed that they were unhappy with the state of America right now.

Declining Figures

Editorial credit: Victor Moussa / Shutterstock.

The Pew Research Center also conducted the study in 2022 and found that people’s confidence in America’s future has declined while their sense of nostalgia has increased. Democrats were more likely to be positive about America’s future than Republicans, though this figure has fallen. However, people in both political parties have a fonder view of the past.

What’s Old Is New Again

Editorial credit: jakkapan / Shutterstock.

We change our focus every few decades to a different “golden age.” The 1980s and 1990s are in, and many people miss those “good old days.” They’ve become the equivalent of what the 1950s were during the ‘80s, and you can see it in all kinds of media. Recently, there have been several TV reboots of shows from those decades, and ‘80s-style music is popular again.

Back to the Future of Nostalgia

Editorial credit: Atmosphere1 / Shutterstock.

Our love for the past goes beyond fashion and is an important part of our psyche. Nowadays, people are starting to miss the neon lights and arcade games of the ‘80s and ‘90s. Remakes and reruns of TV shows and films from these decades are pretty much everywhere. After all, nostalgia’s a pretty powerful drug.

Happy Days

Photo Credit: Universal Pictures.

Of course, this isn’t a new feeling, as shows like “Happy Days” and films like “Back to the Future” also show a sense of nostalgia, but for the ‘50s instead. Humans have always dreamed about the “good old days,” but the decades we feel nostalgic for have changed. Looking at the past through rose-colored glasses is human, but it’s not always helpful.

The History of Nostalgia

Editorial credit: gracious_tiger / Shutterstock.

But it’s not just with the media, as nostalgia has also been a big part of politics. Even when the first Americans were just a memory, politicians like Andrew Jackson used these feelings of nostalgia to gain support. He used people’s love for the “good old days” to win both hearts and votes.

Politicians and Nostalgia

Editorial credit: Aaron of L.A. Photography / Shutterstock.

Many politicians tap into your love for the past because they know it’ll pull at our heartstrings. They ignore or don’t talk about past problems but instead focus on the good bits that we remember. This can be quite powerful, as people like Donald Trump make voters long for times gone by with slogans like “Make America Great Again.”

Just a Fantasy?

Editorial credit: rayjunk / Shutterstock.

While there’s nothing technically wrong with nostalgia, the issue comes from the idea that everything was better in the past. It’s easy to forget that there were just as many problems back then as there are today. Sometimes, our minds play tricks on us by ignoring the bad parts and leaving us with a view of the past that isn’t quite the whole story.

Not So Groovy

Editorial credit: d.ee_angelo/ Shutterstock.

Many people miss the 1970s but have forgotten they were full of problems. This decade was full of issues, like high inflation and gas shortages, not to mention plenty of political problems. It’s easy to romanticize the past, but we often forget what life was like at that time.

Reality Check

Editorial credit: dizain / Shutterstock.

Likewise, if you think crime is bad now, it was actually even worse during the 1970s and 1980s. Statistics show that crime rates were much higher back then, which is enough to make anyone think twice about how good things really were. The facts don’t always support our fond memories of the past, and today is safer than you might think. 

More Positive

Editorial credit: Eugenio Marongiu / Shutterstock.

Similarly, if you look at living standards and people’s quality of life today compared to decades ago, it’s much better. Overall, the economy’s doing a lot better, and people’s lives have generally improved, even in places that most think are poorer. Babies are more likely to grow healthy, and our jobs are safer. Let’s not forget how much medicine and safety regulations have improved, too.

More Time for Fun

Editorial credit: Jelena Stanojkovic / Shutterstock.

We also live longer and have much more free time than ever. Traveling has become cheaper and easier, so people can explore new places for a fraction of the cost before. Being able to do what you want, whether that’s a hobby or just simply spending time with family, is a luxury that past generations never had.

Roomier Homes

Editorial credit: RossHelen / Shutterstock.

Our homes are much bigger than before and have all kinds of comforts that people in the past couldn’t even dream of. For example, some of us have smart home technology that allows us to turn appliances on or off with the touch of a button. We’ve also got smartphones in our pockets that allow us to research anything at all or stay connected with people thousands of miles away.

Societal Improvements

Editorial credit: Rawpixel.com / Shutterstock.

Of course, it’s not just physical things that have improved, as there have been many changes in social rights, too. While things aren’t exactly perfect, there’s not as much of the blatant racism or sexism of 50 years ago. Progress is worth celebrating because it shows we’ve become more inclusive.

Feeling Lost

Editorial credit: fizkes / Shutterstock.

Despite what movies and TV might tell you, people have always felt lost in the modern world, and it’s not something new. That feeling of longing and fear of modernity is something you can trace back even hundreds of years ago. Changes can be scary, and that’s okay, but that doesn’t mean we should resent them.

The Dangers of Looking Back

Editorial credit: Vladimir Borovic/ Shutterstock.

As comforting as it might feel, focusing too much on nostalgia can be harmful, especially in politics. It’s easy for leaders to promise a return to the “good old days,” but those days had their own problems. You’ll only ever be disappointed when you try to return to those times because they’re not as good as you remember.

19 Grim Realities of Dating After 50 That Are Often Overlooked

Editorial credit: fizkes / Shutterstock.

19 Grim Realities of Dating After 50 That Are Often Overlooked

26 Things That Will Be Extinct Because Millennials Refuse to Buy Them

Image Credit: Andriy Solovyov/ Shutterstock.

26 Things That Will Be Extinct Because Millennials Refuse to Buy Them

24 Outdated Slang Terms You Absolutely Shouldn’t Be Using Anymore

Image Credit: oneinchpunch/Shutterstock.

24 Outdated Slang Terms You Absolutely Shouldn’t Be Using Anymore

25 Hardest Parts About Getting Older That No One Ever Talks About

Editorial credit: Ruslan Huzau/ Shutterstock.

25 Hardest Parts About Getting Older That No One Ever Talks About

Leave a Comment

error: Content is protected !!